Why bother, the patient is going to die anyway?

Dear Viki,

I am a physician and need your advice. We had a recent case involving a middle-aged man who had terrible heart attack and was going to die soon. The family wanted us to keep trying and one of the other doctors said, “Why bother, the patient is going to die anyway.” I wasn’t sure what we should do. Should we keep trying to prolong the man’s life even though all we could do is to give him a few more weeks? Is it worth it?

This is a heartbreaking question. The first rule in bioethics is that we should always try to do what the patient has asked us to do. If he wanted us to keep going, even though it was for only a few more weeks, then that is what we should do. If he didn’t want to prolong his dying, then we should allow him to have a peaceful death. You didn’t tell me if he had made his wishes clear so I can’t give you a specific answer.

The next rule that doctors need to follow is that you are only obligated to provide appropriate, beneficial treatments. If you, as a doctor, know that _____ treatment won’t work, you don’t have to offer it. You don’t have to provide inappropriate and ineffective medicine no matter how hard the patient’s family begs for it. Patients have the right to refuse any treatment but they do not have the right to demand inappropriate treatments. You get to exercise your good medical judgment.

Here is where the real ethical conflict is in this case. Since you could keep him alive for a few more weeks, then the issue was not whether or not it was possible medically, but whether or not it was the “right” thing to do for this particular patient. Did keeping him alive provide him with the quality of life that he would want? To answer the question, “Is it worth it?”, we would have to ask the patient and if he wasn’t able to tell us, then we would need to ask his loved ones what he would say. For some people, lingering for a few weeks would only prolong their pain and suffering. For others, there may be tremendous meaning in those last weeks.

I think that as healthcare professionals, we sometimes forget that a few more days may mean the world to everyone involved. Whether it gives people time to travel to say their goodbyes or to make peace with the impending death, it matters. This case reminds me that we have to ask people what they would want so we will know how to care for them when their time comes. Ultimately, this comes down to respecting our patients while we practice good medicine.